Menu

The Ultimate Cheese Toastie

19 June 2025 — Lunch, Snack

Ultimate Cheese Toastie

Ingredients

2 slices of white or brown bread

25g butter

75g Wyfe of Bath

Chutney of your choice (we like to use Sticky Fig Relish)

Ham (optional)

Onion (optional)

How to make it

This golden, melty cheese toastie combines creamy, nutty flavours with a perfectly crisp exterior—an easy yet indulgent twist on the classic grilled sandwich.

  • Butter each slice of bread on one side
  • Arrange the Wyfe of Bath on one slice of bread
  • Add the chutney, onion and ham (optional)
  • If you have a sandwich toaster, pop it in there for approximately 5 minutes until the bread is golden brown and the cheese has melted.
  • If you don’t have a sandwich toaster, you can do this in a frying pan on under the grill
  • Cut your toastie in half and enjoy with a delicious side salad

Recipe Courtesy of Bath Soft Cheese Co.

 

Other recipes

Sourdough Emmental toastie stuffed with salt beef, sauerkraut and dill mustard sauce is the sandwich choice of connoisseurs. Eat with a side of gherkins and a twist of the moustache tip.

A bite of this Tracklements Fresh Chilli Jam cheese toastie will make you wonder where it has been all your life.

Here’s a classic croque monsieur with the added twist of blue cheese and crusty ciabatta makes for a decadent lunch!

Ploughman’s is the quintessential British sandwich. It’s just the ticket for an on-the-go lunch and is sure to keep you stuffed until dinner.

Leave a Reply

Artisan Cheese Gift Boxes

Choose one of our selected boxes, perfect for yourself or a gift…

Artisan Cheese Subscriptions

Join our cheese club and receive a regular delivery direct to your door…

Individual Artisan Cheeses

Make up your own box, choose three and we’ll give you one free!